CO129-121 - Sir MacDonnell - 1867 [3-4] — Page 115

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

H

notification dated same day received a such appointment in an Official letter from Mor Mercer, the Colonial Secretary; and

the latter unofficially communicated to the Chief Justice the nomination of Mr Ball on the day it was made.

5

On the morning of the 18th, the usual day for holding the Sessions, the Chief Justice called on Mr Ball for his authority to act, and the latter produced the Official letter from the Colonial Secretary. The Chief Justice, however, expressed himself as much embarrassed by doubts, and I enclose Mr Ball's statement of what had occurred in court on the subject.

Enclosure 2.

111

The Chief Justice, as Your Lordship will perceive, had taken his seat on the Bench with a schedule of his doubts in the form of ten Queries, which I also enclose, with comments made on each by the Colonial Secretary. The Chief Justice appears to have been anxious to argue each of those Queries with Mr Ball, who, on the other hand, had no argument to advance, except that he believed his appointment to be perfectly valid, and if not, that in the opinion of the Chief Justice, he had "locus standi" in the court.

7

The Chief Justice then adjourned the court to a future day, and Mr Ball having subsequently nothing more to advance, he adjourned it again; there being many cases instead of only six cases.

Edit History

2026-05-19 17:05:53 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
H notification dated same day received a such appointment in an Official letter from Mor Mercer, the Colonial Secretary; and the latter unofficially communicated to the Chief Justice the nomination of Mr Ball on the day it was made. 5 On the morning of the 18th, the usual day for holding the Sessions, the Chief Justice called on Mr Ball for his authority to act, and the latter produced the Official letter from the Colonial Secretary. The Chief Justice, however, expressed himself as much embarrassed by doubts, and I enclose Mr Ball's statement of what had occurred in court on the subject. Enclosure 2. 111 The Chief Justice, as Your Lordship will perceive, had taken his seat on the Bench with a schedule of his doubts in the form of ten Queries, which I also enclose, with comments made on each by the Colonial Secretary. The Chief Justice appears to have been anxious to argue each of those Queries with Mr Ball, who, on the other hand, had no argument to advance, except that he believed his appointment to be perfectly valid, and if not, that in the opinion of the Chief Justice, he had "locus standi" in the court. 7 The Chief Justice then adjourned the court to a future day, and Mr Ball having subsequently nothing more to advance, he adjourned it again; there being many cases instead of only six cases.
Baseline (Original)
H notification dated same day of preceived a such appointment in an Official letter from Mor Mercer, the Colonial Secretary- and Enclosure S. the latter unofficially communicated to the Chief Justice the nomination of Mr Ball day it was made. on the 5 On the morning of the 18th, the CH- usual day for holding the Sessions, the Chief Justice called om Mr Ball for his authority to act, and the latter produced the Official letter from the Colonial Secretary The Chief protice however expressed himself as much embarrassed by doubts, and I enclope Mr Balls statement the same of what had occurred in bourt subject. ملا .om the day The Chief Justice, as Your Lordship Enclosure 2. 111 com the will perceive, had taken his peat Bench with a schedule of his doubts in the form of ten Queries which I also Enclosure 3. enclope, with made a comment om each since by the Colonial Secretary - The Chief justice appears to have been anxious to each of those Queries with M.Ball, arque who on the other hand had no argument to advance, except that he believed his appointment to be perfectly valid, and if not to in the opinion of the Chief Justice that he had то "locus standi" in the bourt. 7 The Chief Justice then adjourned the bourt to a future day, and, Mr Ball having subsequently nothing mare advance, he adjourned it again; there been many to and had instead of only six cases
2026-05-19 17:05:53 · Baseline
View content

H

notification dated same

day of preceived a such appointment in an Official letter from Mor Mercer, the Colonial Secretary- and

Enclosure S.

the latter unofficially communicated to the

Chief Justice

the nomination of Mr Ball

day it was made.

on the

5

On the

morning of the 18th, the

CH-

usual day for holding the Sessions, the

Chief Justice

called

om

Mr Ball for his

authority to act, and the latter produced the Official letter from the Colonial Secretary The Chief protice however expressed himself as much embarrassed by doubts, and I

enclope Mr Balls statement the same of what had occurred in bourt

subject.

ملا

.om

the

day

The Chief Justice, as Your Lordship

Enclosure 2.

111

com

the

will perceive, had taken his peat Bench with

a schedule of his doubts in

the form of ten Queries which I also

Enclosure 3. enclope, with

made

a comment

om

each since

by the Colonial Secretary - The Chief

justice appears to have been anxious to

each of those Queries with M.Ball,

arque

who on the other hand had no

argument

to advance, except that he believed his appointment to be perfectly valid, and if not to in the opinion of the Chief Justice that

he had

то

"locus standi" in the bourt.

7

The Chief Justice then

adjourned

the bourt to a future day, and, Mr Ball

having subsequently nothing

mare

advance, he adjourned it again;

there been

many

to

and had

instead of only six cases

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.